Balancing the Federal Budget
Fiscal Discipline and the Circumstances That Made It Possible
Throughout American history, the federal budget has rarely been in true balance. The idea of spending only what is collected in revenue has been a political ideal more than a consistent practice. However, there have been distinct periods when balanced budgets or even surpluses were achieved. These moments were shaped not only by political will but also by a confluence of favorable economic conditions, wartime demobilizations, tax reforms and, at times, austerity. I thought it a good day to examine when the U.S. balanced its budget in the past and what was required to make it happen.
The Early Republic and Jeffersonian Austerity (1801–1809)
Circumstances:
Thomas Jefferson inherited a national debt of roughly $83 million in 1801, a result of Revolutionary War borrowing and Alexander Hamilton’s consolidation of state debts.
Jefferson and Treasury Secretary Albert Gallatin prioritized debt reduction as a moral obligation.
Necessaries:
Slashed military expenditures, particularly the Navy.
Eliminated many internal taxes, relying primarily on tariffs and land sales.
A strong export-driven economy in agriculture helped sustain revenue.
Outcome:
The national debt was significantly reduced during Jefferson’s presidency. Though not a balanced budget in the modern accounting sense, revenue routinely exceeded non-debt expenditures.
Post-Civil War Surpluses (1870s–1890s)
Circumstances:
After the Civil War, the federal government ran consistent surpluses, using them to pay down the massive wartime debt.
Necessaries:
High tariffs under Republican administrations generated abundant revenue.
Limited federal spending, especially as Reconstruction ended and the federal role in the South waned.
Avoidance of entitlement spending, which did not yet exist.
Outcome:
Budget surpluses persisted for decades. By 1893, the national debt had fallen to $1 billion from a wartime high of $2.7 billion.
The Coolidge Era and Budget Surpluses of the 1920s
Circumstances:
Following World War I, the federal government sought to restrain spending and reduce debt.
Necessaries:
President Calvin Coolidge and his budget director Charles Dawes focused intensely on budgetary discipline.
The Budget and Accounting Act of 1921 created the Bureau of the Budget (now the OMB), centralizing executive control over expenditures.
The Revenue Acts of the 1920s gradually reduced income tax rates but sustained strong revenue through economic growth.
Outcome:
Between 1920 and 1930, the U.S. ran multiple budget surpluses, significantly cutting the national debt and fueling economic optimism until the Great Depression struck.
World War II Demobilization and the 1947–1949 Surpluses
Circumstances:
World War II had generated enormous debt, but the postwar economy boomed.
Returning soldiers and war production shifted into domestic economic expansion.
Necessaries:
Massive reduction in military spending following victory.
Wartime tax increases remained in place, generating high revenue.
GI Bill and federal investments helped expand the middle class and workforce participation.
Outcome:
The federal government ran budget surpluses in 1947, 1948 and 1949, aided by the economic transition from wartime to peacetime production.
The Eisenhower Years: Defense Spending and Selective Cuts (1953–1961)
Circumstances:
President Dwight D. Eisenhower, a former general, took a cautious approach to both taxes and spending.
His administration balanced the budget in 1956, 1957 and nearly in other years.
Necessaries:
Maintained relatively high taxes from the WWII era.
Prioritized balanced budgets over expansive domestic programs, though he approved the Interstate Highway Act.
Outcome:
Eisenhower’s fiscal conservatism led to modest surpluses and restrained growth in debt, though not elimination of it.
The Clinton Surpluses (1998–2001)
Circumstances:
After decades of growing deficits, the U.S. entered a tech-driven economic boom.
The Cold War ended, leading to reduced military spending.
Necessaries:
1993 Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act raised taxes on higher earners and restrained spending.
Bipartisan Budget Act of 1997 capped discretionary spending and reduced entitlement growth.
Strong economic growth boosted revenues through capital gains and income taxes.
Outcome:
From 1998 to 2001, the U.S. recorded four consecutive budget surpluses, the first since 1969. Public debt actually decreased in nominal terms.
Common Elements to Achieve Balanced Budgets
Economic Growth: Balanced budgets almost never occur during recessions. Growth boosts tax revenues and reduces the need for emergency spending.
Controlled Spending: Whether through austerity or prioritization (especially on defense), spending restraint is a hallmark.
Revenue Measures: Balanced budgets have typically required robust tax collections, often unpopular but necessary.
War or Crisis Resolution: Surpluses often follow demobilizations (post-Civil War, WWII, Cold War), when military costs fall dramatically.
Political Consensus: Successful efforts have generally involved cross-party cooperation or strong presidential leadership focused on fiscal discipline.
Balancing the U.S. budget in the past never happened by accident. It required deliberate, sometimes unpopular policy choices, as well as a favorable economic climate.
With today's rising entitlement spending, demographic shifts and political polarization, the pathway to balancing the budget may be narrower than in the past. History shows, however, that when fiscal necessity meets political will, balance is not impossible.
My column sees the world through the lens of Americana and focuses primarily on the culture and history of the United States. It uses the latest technological innovations combined with over seven decades of personal experience to create a vehicle that helps to communicate issues that have resonated throughout the history of the American experiment. My column is free to all but also offers a modest paid subscription for those who want to support the free flow of ideas.